TradeCalculator.co.uk
Gas vs Electric vs Oil Heating — UK Costs
Comparing UK heating fuel options — running costs per kWh, efficiency, carbon emissions, future-proofing and the transition away from fossil fuels.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Property | Gas Boiler | Oil Boiler | Electric Boiler | Heat Pump |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fuel cost (p/kWh) | ~7p | ~7p | ~26p | ~26p (but COP 3+) |
| Effective heat cost | ~7.9p/kWh | ~7.8p/kWh | ~26p/kWh | ~7-9p/kWh |
| Boiler efficiency | 92-94% | 90-93% | 99-100% | 280-400% (COP) |
| Annual cost (3-bed) | £800-1,200 | £900-1,400 | £2,500-3,500 | £600-1,000 |
| CO2 per kWh heat | ~200g | ~270g | ~136g | ~40-50g |
| Boiler replacement | £2,000-3,500 | £3,000-5,000 | £1,500-3,000 | £8,000-14,000 |
| Fuel storage | None (mains supply) | Oil tank (1000-2500L) | None | None |
| Future-proofing | Phase-out by 2035 | Phase-out starting | Expensive to run | Government-backed future |
UK Running Cost Comparison (2026)
For a typical 3-bedroom semi-detached house using 12,000 kWh/year of heat:
| Heating System | Annual fuel cost | Annual service | Total/year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gas combi boiler (93% eff.) | £950 | £80-120 | £1,030-1,070 |
| Oil boiler (90% eff.) | £930 | £100-150 | £1,030-1,080 |
| Electric boiler (100% eff.) | £3,130 | £0 | £3,130 |
| ASHP (COP 3.0) | £1,040 | £100-150 | £1,140-1,190 |
| GSHP (COP 4.0) | £780 | £100-150 | £880-930 |
When to Choose Each
Stick With Gas When
- Current gas boiler needs replacing
- Budget for heat pump is not available
- Property is poorly insulated (upgrade first)
- Plan to upgrade to heat pump within 10 years
Switch to Heat Pump When
- Property is well insulated (EPC C or better)
- BUS grant makes it affordable
- Replacing oil or LPG system
- New build or major renovation
Environmental Considerations
The UK grid carbon intensity has fallen from 500g CO2/kWh in 2012 to 136g in 2024 (DESNZ), making electric heating (especially heat pumps) increasingly clean. Gas and oil emit CO2 at the point of combustion — there is no way to reduce this. Hydrogen boilers are a potential future option for the gas grid but remain unproven at scale. For the lowest carbon footprint now, a heat pump with a green electricity tariff is the best option.
Related Calculators
- Boiler Size Calculator — calculate the right boiler output for your home
- Heat Loss Calculator — assess your property heat loss
How We Calculate This
Frequently Asked Questions
Related Calculators
Heat Pump vs Gas Boiler
Compare air source heat pumps with gas boilers — running costs, BUS grant, COP and carbon emissions.
Electric vs Wet Underfloor Heating
Compare electric mat and wet hydronic underfloor heating — cost, floor buildup and running costs.
Air Source vs Ground Source Heat Pump
ASHP vs GSHP: COP ratings, installation costs, space requirements and running costs.
Heat Pump Brands Comparison
Compare Mitsubishi, Daikin, Samsung, Vaillant and Grant heat pumps on COP, noise and warranty.
Was this calculator helpful?
Last updated: July 2026
Verified against UK standards · estimates only, confirm with your supplier.